While I love a HomeGoods or Target run (or if you’re in Fairfield, Vintage Garden or Beehive!) to grab closing gifts for our clients, I’ve also scoured the internet for more personal and unique gifts for the new homeowner in your life.
The best gifts are gifts your friend wouldn’t buy themselves, and these 10 gifts encapsulate the perfect housewarming gift they’re sure to treasure.
*prices reflect date of 5/13/26*
Custom Tumbled Stone City Map Coaster from Etsy | $12.78 – $76.68
Each of these tile coasters is individually cut with a birds-eye view of the city of your choice.
Custom Return Address Stamps from Simply Stamps | $12.99 – $31.99
The perfect little gift for a new homeowner who also loves to send mail.
Heart Cut-Out State Wood Sign from Etsy | $27
This rustic, hand-painted board lets everyone know where your heart is!
Little Free Library kit from Little Free Library | $189.95 – $439.95
For the book lover in your life, these kits come with pre-cut pieces, hardware, and instructions.
“First Christmas” Ornament | $15.93 – $21.15
Zazzle has a ton of options for Christmas ornaments. Bonus if you can get it engraved with their new address!
Custom Watercolor House Portrait by Alexis Seabrook | $350 – $450
For the prettiest, most detailed watercolor house portrait, there’s no one better. A house portrait will be a lovely talking piece in a new home.
Personalized Party Tub, Ice Bucket or Wine Chiller from Things Remembered | $32.89 – $59.49
For the entertainer in your life, these stainless steel buckets will serve a purpose and look chic while they do it!
State Spoon Rest from Uncommon Goods | $28
Perfect if your friend is moving to a new state (or if you want to give them something to remember their old state by!)
Personalized Dog ID Tag from Chewy
For your friends moving with their pup, send them a custom dog tag with their new address. It’s one less thing they have to worry about.
Gift Card to Local Restaurant
While this may not be so unique, it will definitely be appreciated. Research what restaurants have the best reviews and pick up a gift card. Dinner’s on you!